katikat: (Default)
don't be dull, be fannish ([personal profile] katikat) wrote2010-01-08 09:24 am

Of RPS

Wow, I still can't believe that Supernatural won the People's Choice Award for best SF/F show. Wow! Congratulations! I hope that we will get to see Kripke talking about it, on the S5 DVD box set if nothing else.

And both Jared and Jensen are engaged to be married very, very soon if the rumors are true. Congratulations. But that's rather it for me. I'm not really interested in the personal lives of the actors. Sure, it's cute to hear about their dogs or how Jared sucks at golfing - but I could care less about their love life *shrugs*

I'm not and I've never been a fan of either Danneel Harris or Genevieve Cortese (or Sandy McCoy before that). I've seen them in various shows and they never made an impression on me. I'm not bashing them, I'm just not their fan, I don't go out of my way to find their movies/series. They aren't more beautiful or more talented than dozens of other actresses. And just because I'm a fan of Jared and Jensen, there's no fan law that orders me to automatically become a fan of their soon-to-be-wives - remember the mess when Jared and Sandy broke up? No, thank you. And it makes me rather annoyed that a big part of the fandom accuses me of being a bad fan or, I don't know, a wanker if I don't immediately become a fan of Danneel and Genevieve by proxy. I think it's actually rather insulting for the actresses if you become their fan just because they are someone's fiancées.

Which brings me to the point of my entry - RPS fics and J2 in this case. Yes, I still read CWRPS stories regardless of the marital status of the actors. Why? Because 95% of stories that I read are AUs with original characters that are modeled after Jared and Jensen and that's it. If they were named Dick and Larry instead of Jared and Jensen, nothing would change. There are stories with businessman!Jensen and veterinarian!Jared, singer!Jensen and ranch-owner!Jared, physical-therapist!Jensen and assassin!Jared etc. etc. I read these fics as I would watch a movie where the characters are portrayed by Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki. And those have nothing to do with the personal lives of the actors.

Enough meta-ing for 9am!
ext_2619: Fred from Angel, reading a book. ([sg1] vala :: princess)

here from metafandom.

[identity profile] noelia-g.livejournal.com 2010-01-10 10:34 pm (UTC)(link)
I really like your way of comparing RPS AUs to actors portraying characters in the movies - this is what I've been trying to explain for a while, only not so well.

With RPS, I take some fanon-established traits of 'Jared' and 'Jensen' characters I read about, that happen to be based on real people whose personalities we see on the interviews, etc; but I don't think those have much to do with, well, reality (it's true about non-J2 RPFiction I read, too). In fact, the less I know about the actors' personal life, the easier it is for me to read RPS.

I like Genevieve, quite a bit, and I am pleased she's in Flash Forward. It has nothing to do with her relationships. I understand she's not everyone's favourite actress, I don't expect everyone to have the same taste in actors and actresses as I do. I had seen very little of Danneel in shows or movies I watch, so I have no opinion as of yet.

I don't know, all this noise seems kind of pointless to me, I'd prefer people doing much more productive things with their time than arguing about the actors' relationships. Like, write more fic. This would please me ;D

(tl;dr: I liked your post. I'll go and read RPS fic now. And then catch up on Flash Forward.)

Re: here from metafandom.

[identity profile] katikat.livejournal.com 2010-01-11 04:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Hi there *waves* CWRPS fics are the only ones that I read and I do prefer the AUs - I love gay romances, one of my favorite genres, so the AUs are like, I don't know, watching a movie with them playing those roles. I know that some people write original stories and just post a picture of the actor with the name of their original character to show how they imagine him/her - I know that there used to be this really long gen but slashy scifi series and the author imagined one of her characters as Martin Cummins, the other one as Keanu Reeves. RPS AUs are basically the same, they just keep the name of the actor...